The Core Problem: Valuing Intangible Assets in Bankruptcy is Complex

Have you ever wondered what happens to a tech company’s most valuable assets such as its software, algorithms, or intellectual property when it goes bankrupt? In the modern economy, a business’s true worth is often intangible. While traditional insolvency focuses on liquidating physical assets, the process of valuing intangible assets in bankruptcy presents a unique and hidden challenge, particularly for IT businesses. According to PwC, over 70% of modern corporate value now comes from intangible assets, yet valuing these assets during a crisis remains one of the most contentious and misunderstood processes in corporate restructuring.

For business leaders and creditors, the stakes are incredibly high. A miscalculation can lead to significant financial losses and fierce legal disputes. This article explores the biggest challenges in valuing intangible assets in bankruptcy, offering a comprehensive analysis and actionable strategies for navigating the complexities of IT insolvency.

When an IT company faces insolvency, its tangible assets, like office equipment or servers, often contribute less than 20% of its total value (Statista, 2024). The real worth lies in its proprietary software, patents, and customer databases. Valuing these assets is critical because they form the lion’s share of a tech firm’s worth. However, their nature makes them difficult to quantify, especially under the pressure of insolvency proceedings.

Creditor disputes over fair recovery.

Investor mistrust due to opaque valuation models.

Regulatory scrutiny under frameworks like India’s Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC).

In short, inaccurate IP valuation risks both financial losses and reputational damage during IT insolvency proceedings. Creditors scrutinise these valuations closely because they directly impact their recovery rates.

The Biggest Challenges in Valuing Intangible Assets in Bankruptcy

Subjectivity of IP Valuation and Lack of Standardisation

Unlike a piece of machinery with a clear market value, the worth of intellectual property is highly subjective. The value of software depends on its scalability, market adoption, and integration potential. Deloitte reports that up to 45% of IP valuations differ significantly depending on the methodology applied. A 2023 PwC report notes that 65% of insolvency professionals struggle to align valuation methods with the unique characteristics of intangible assets, leading to disputes among stakeholders. The lack of a universal standard for valuing intangible assets in bankruptcy is a primary cause of conflict.

Rapid Technological Obsolescence

The IT industry faces constant innovation. A market-leading software can lose significant value within 12–18 months. Valuing intangible assets in bankruptcy requires assessing their current and future utility, which is incredibly challenging when technology evolves so rapidly. McKinsey estimates that software-driven companies lose 10–15% of their intangible asset value annually due to technological obsolescence. This rapid depreciation makes it difficult for valuers to provide a realistic picture to creditors during IT insolvency.

Intense Creditor Scrutiny and Regulatory Pressure

Creditors, especially in IT insolvency cases, demand detailed evidence on projected cash flows, user base stickiness, and licensing rights. Under India’s IBC and US bankruptcy courts, disclosure standards for intangible assets are becoming increasingly strict. A 2022 Bloomberg analysis found that creditor disputes over intangible asset valuations delayed 30% of IT insolvency resolutions. This scrutiny slows proceedings and raises costs, highlighting the importance of a defensible valuation for all parties involved in an IT insolvency.

Legal and Cross-Border Complications

IP valuation during IT insolvency often faces legal hurdles. Patents or trademarks may be tied to complex licensing agreements or ongoing litigation, reducing their marketability. For global IT businesses, software rights and IP licensing often extend across jurisdictions. Aligning valuations across different legal systems is both time-consuming and contentious. A Reuters article from 2024 highlights that 40% of IT bankruptcy cases involve legal challenges related to IP ownership, adding a layer of complexity to valuing intangible assets in bankruptcy.

Limited Secondary Markets

While physical assets can be auctioned easily, IP assets lack a deep secondary market. A patent that appears valuable may not find buyers willing to pay its book value. This disconnect creates significant uncertainty for insolvency professionals. Deloitte reports that 25% of IT firms in bankruptcy face valuation discounts on data assets due to compliance and security risks, further complicating the process.

Expert Insight: A Hybrid Approach is Essential

“Valuing intangible assets in bankruptcy is like trying to price a moving target,” says Jane Thompson, a senior insolvency consultant at PwC. “You need a deep understanding of the technology, market trends, and legal frameworks to get it right.” This perspective underscores why IT insolvency professionals increasingly rely on cross-functional teams rather than single-discipline appraisers. Valuing intangible assets in bankruptcy requires a hybrid lens, combining financial, legal, and technological expertise.

Real-World Example: A Cautionary Tale

In 2023, an Indian SaaS firm filed for insolvency under the IBC. Despite having cutting-edge AI software, disagreements over its value led to a six-month delay in creditor resolution. While tangible assets worth only ₹30 crore were liquidated quickly, debates on IP valuation involving projected revenues of over ₹250 crore stalled proceedings. This case illustrates the critical stakes in IP valuation during IT insolvency and how valuing intangible assets in bankruptcy can determine a company’s fate.

The Future of Valuing Intangible Assets in Bankruptcy

Looking ahead, the process of valuing intangible assets in bankruptcy will evolve. We can anticipate several key trends:

• AI-Driven Valuation Tools: AI and machine learning will be developed to predict the future value of software and IP, reducing reliance on speculative models. McKinsey predicts that 30% of insolvency valuations will use AI tools by 2027.
• Blockchain for IP Transparency: Blockchain technology could streamline IP valuation by providing immutable records of ownership and licensing, reducing disputes in insolvency proceedings.
• Increased Regulatory Scrutiny: As data privacy laws tighten, valuing data assets will require stricter compliance, potentially lowering their market value in bankruptcy.

Strategic Recommendations for Business Leaders

• Engage expert valuators early: Partner with valuation specialists familiar with IT insolvency to ensure accurate assessments of software and IP.
• Document asset provenance: Maintain clear records of IP ownership and licensing agreements to avoid legal disputes during bankruptcy.
• Monitor technological relevance: Regularly assess the market relevance of your intangible assets to mitigate obsolescence risks.
• Communicate with creditors: Proactively address creditor scrutiny by providing transparent valuation methodologies and market data.
• Leverage technology: Explore AI-driven valuation tools to enhance accuracy and speed in valuing intangible assets in bankruptcy.

Conclusion: Turning Complexity into Strategic Advantage

Valuing intangible assets in bankruptcy is not just a compliance exercise; it is a strategic determinant of survival for IT businesses. Companies that treat IP valuation as a proactive discipline rather than a reactive crisis tool are more likely to safeguard value during IT insolvency. By embracing transparent, data-driven, and cross-functional approaches, business leaders can navigate this complex landscape with confidence. The future of IT insolvency lies in a prepared approach to intangible assets.

About LawCrust

LawCrust Global Consulting Ltd. delivers cutting-edge Hybrid Consulting Solutions in Management, Finance, Technology, and Legal Consulting to ambitious businesses worldwide. Recognised for our cross-functional expertise and hybrid consulting approach, we empower startups, SMEs, and enterprises to scale efficiently, innovate boldly, and navigate complexity with confidence. Our services span key areas such as Investment Banking, Fundraising, Mergers & Acquisitions, Private Placement, and Debt Restructuring & Transformation, positioning us as a strategic partner for growth and resilience. With an integrated consulting model, fixed-cost engagements, and a virtual delivery framework, we make business transformation accessible, agile, and impactful.

For expert legal help, please contact us:

• Email: inquiry@lawcrustbusiness.com