Raise Capital Without Formal Valuation: Navigating Private Placements in India

Private placement, as defined under Section 42 of the Companies Act, 2013, is a strategic mechanism for Indian startups and mid-market companies to raise capital by issuing securities to a select group of investors without a public offering. This approach is favored for its flexibility and ability to engage strategic or high-net-worth investors directly. A key question for founders is: Can you raise capital without a formal valuation? This article explores how Indian companies can customise private placement funding to raise capital without a formal valuation, ensuring compliance with SEBI, MCA, and RBI frameworks while maintaining investor trust.

Understanding Valuation Requirements to Raise Capital Without Formal Valuation

• Is a Formal Valuation Report Always Needed?

Raising capital without a formal valuation is feasible in certain private placement scenarios, depending on the securities issued and transaction structure. Under the Companies Act, 2013, private placement funding typically involves equity shares, compulsorily convertible preference shares (CCPS), or compulsorily convertible debentures (CCDs). While a valuation report by a registered valuer is recommended, it’s not always mandatory for private companies issuing securities to resident investors. Rule 13 of the Companies (Share Capital and Debentures) Rules, 2014, mandates valuation for equity issued to non-residents or at a premium above fair market value. However, companies can often raise capital without a formal valuation by relying on investor-driven pricing agreements for resident investors or convertible instruments.

• Distinction Between Equity, CCPS, and CCD

The need for a formal valuation varies by instrument:

1. Equity Shares: Issuing equity shares, especially for non-residents or sweat equity, requires a registered valuer’s report to comply with FEMA or MCA rules. This ensures fair market value pricing, critical for RBI’s FDI guidelines.
2. CCPS and CCD: Convertible instruments provide flexibility to raise capital without a formal valuation. By using valuation caps or discount rates, companies can defer valuation to a future funding round, making these instruments ideal for early-stage startups.

• When Is Valuation by a Registered Valuer Mandatory?

A registered valuer’s report is mandatory in these cases:

1. Equity issuance to non-residents under FEMA’s FDI pricing guidelines.
2. Securities issued at a premium exceeding fair market value, per Rule 13.
3. Related-party transactions requiring arm’s-length pricing.

For private placements to resident investors using convertible instruments, companies can often raise capital without a formal valuation, provided pricing is transparent and mutually agreed upon.

1. Investor Perspective: Assessing Startups Without Formal Valuation

• How Investors Evaluate Without a Valuation Report

Investors in early-stage startups often assess value without a formal valuation report, focusing on qualitative and quantitative metrics. To raise capital without a formal valuation, founders must demonstrate:

1. Revenue Traction: Consistent revenue growth signals market demand.
2. Intellectual Property (IP): Patents or proprietary technology enhance perceived value.
3. Team Strength: A skilled founding team builds investor confidence.
4. Market Opportunity: A large, growing market justifies investment potential.
5. Competitive Positioning: A clear edge over competitors strengthens the case.

This investor valuation approach allows startups to raise capital without a formal valuation by aligning with investor priorities.

• Convertible Instruments to Defer Valuation

Convertible instruments like CCPS or CCDs are effective tools to raise capital without a formal valuation. These instruments use mechanisms like valuation caps or discounts (e.g., 20% off the next round’s valuation), deferring definitive valuation to a future priced round. This approach balances founder flexibility with investor protection, making it a popular choice for private placement funding.

• Informal Business Valuation Methods

In negotiations, informal business valuation methods bridge the gap when a formal report is absent:

• Comparable Company Analysis: Benchmarking against similar firms.
• Discounted Cash Flow (DCF): Estimating future cash flows, though less reliable for early-stage startups.
• Market Multiples: Applying industry-standard revenue or EBITDA multiples.

These methods enable founders to raise capital without a formal valuation while maintaining transparent investor discussions.

2. Legal and Compliance Insights

• SEBI ICDR Guidelines vs. Private Company Exemptions

SEBI’s Issue of Capital and Disclosure Requirements (ICDR) Regulations, 2018, impose strict valuation rules for listed companies. However, unlisted private companies enjoy exemptions, providing flexibility to raise capital without a formal valuation under the Companies Act, 2013. Compliance with Section 42 and Rule 14 remains critical for private placement compliance.

• MCA Compliance Requirements

To raise capital without a formal valuation, private companies must adhere to:

1. Form PAS-4: Issue a private placement offer letter detailing terms, pricing, and investor rights, shared with up to 200 identified investors (excluding QIBs and employees).0
2. Form PAS-3: File a return of allotment with the MCA within 15 days of issuing securities.
3. Shareholder Resolutions: Obtain a special resolution approving the private placement and pricing terms.

• RBI Rules for Foreign Investors

When foreign investors are involved, RBI’s FDI pricing guidelines mandate that equity shares be priced at or above fair market value, determined by a registered valuer or SEBI-registered merchant banker. For CCPS or CCDs, valuation can be deferred, but conversion prices must comply with RBI rules. This limits the ability to raise capital without a formal valuation in FDI scenarios, requiring careful legal oversight.

3. Best Practices to Raise Capital Without Formal Valuation

• When to Opt for No Formal Valuation

Raising capital without a formal valuation is suitable when:

1. Issuing CCPS or CCDs to resident investors.
2. The company is early-stage with limited financial data.
3. Investors prioritise strategic alignment over formal valuation.

• Avoid skipping valuation for:

1. Equity issuance to non-residents, due to RBI mandates.
2. Large raises where investors demand formal valuation for transparency.
3. Related-party transactions requiring arm’s-length pricing.

4. Drafting Investor Rights Agreements

To protect stakeholders when raising capital without a formal valuation, include:

• Anti-Dilution Clauses: Safeguard investors from lower valuations in future rounds.
• Valuation Caps: Set a ceiling for convertible instrument conversions.
• Discount Mechanisms: Offer discounts on future equity pricing.
• Information Rights: Provide regular financial updates to build trust.

5. Engage Legal Counsel Early

Legal counsel ensures private placement compliance, reviews offer documents, and navigates MCA, SEBI, and RBI regulations. Early engagement prevents costly errors and supports raising capital without a formal valuation.

Case Example: NutriBite’s Strategic Fundraise

NutriBite, a consumer goods startup, raised ₹15 Cr through a private placement of CCDs to strategic angel investors without a formal valuation report. The CCDs featured a ₹50 Cr valuation cap and a 20% discount on the Series A valuation, deferring formal valuation. By filing Form PAS-4 and PAS-3, securing shareholder resolutions, and confirming compliance with MCA (and RBI, as all investors were Indian residents), NutriBite successfully raised capital without a formal valuation, aligning investor and founder interests.

Conclusion

Raising capital without a formal valuation through private placement is a viable strategy for Indian startups and mid-market companies, particularly when using convertible instruments like CCPS or CCDs. By leveraging informal business valuation methods, transparent investor communication, and strict adherence to MCA, SEBI, and RBI frameworks, founders can accelerate fundraising while ensuring private placement compliance. Engaging legal counsel and incorporating protective clauses in investor agreements further safeguard trust and regulatory integrity, enabling companies to raise capital without a formal valuation effectively.

About LawCrust

LawCrust Global Consulting Ltd. delivers cutting-edge Hybrid Consulting Solutions in Management, Finance, Technology, and Legal Consulting to ambitious businesses worldwide. Recognised for our cross-functional expertise and hybrid consulting approach, we empower startups, SMEs, and enterprises to scale efficiently, innovate boldly, and navigate complexity with confidence. Our services span key areas such as Investment Banking, Fundraising, Mergers & Acquisitions, Private Placement, and Debt Restructuring & Transformation, positioning us as a strategic partner for growth and resilience. With an integrated consulting model, fixed-cost engagements, and a virtual delivery framework, we make business transformation accessible, agile, and impactful.

For expert legal help, please contact us:

• Email: inquiry@lawcrustbusiness.com