Navigating Overpayment Risks in India’s IT M&A Boom

India’s Information Technology (IT) sector is a global leader, and its mergers and acquisitions (M&A) market is surging, driven by strategic imperatives and competitive pressures. However, overpayment risks threaten to undermine deal value, making disciplined due diligence and valuation critical for senior leaders. This article explores the IT M&A landscape, identifies key overpayment risks, and provides a strategic playbook to ensure sustainable deal success in India’s dynamic market.

Industry Context: The IT M&A Surge and Overpayment Risks

India’s IT M&A market is thriving, with 669 deals worth $29 billion in Q1 2025, a multi-year high. Inbound investments from global players target India’s talent and innovation, while outbound acquisitions by Indian firms focus on market expansion, niche technologies (SaaS, cybersecurity, AI, cloud services), and talent acqui-hires through Global Capability Center (GCC) spin-offs. These deals aim to secure competitive advantages but carry significant overpayment risks due to inflated valuations.

Post-COVID, valuation dynamics have shifted. The pandemic accelerated digital transformation, intensifying competition for specialised capabilities. SaaS and AI startups now command EV/EBITDA multiples of 15-20x, up from 10-12x pre-COVID, driven by private equity (PE) dry powder ($126 billion in Asia-Pacific) and bidding wars. These premiums heighten overpayment risks, requiring rigorous due diligence and disciplined deal pricing to protect shareholder value.

1. Recent Trends: Signals of Overpayment Risks

As of June 2025, large-ticket IT M&A deals dominate headlines. For example, New Mountain Capital’s $2 billion acquisition of Chennai-based Access Healthcare Services underscores the appeal of tech-enabled services. However, high-profile overpayment incidents highlight risks. A mid-sized IT firm paid a 30% premium for a cloud analytics company, only to discover inflated revenue projections due to overstated contracts, a classic valuation error.

Generative AI (GenAI) valuations further complicate deal pricing, with speculative multiples driving overpayment risks. SEBI’s 2025 guidelines mandate fair disclosure and valuation fairness opinions for listed acquirers, requiring detailed justification of deal valuations and transparency in related-party transactions. These rules aim to curb overpayment risks, compelling companies to strengthen governance and due diligence.

2. Identifying Overpayment Risks and Valuation Errors

• Overpayment risks arise from multiple sources, undermining deal value:

1. Overestimating Synergy Benefits: Acquirers often project optimistic cost or revenue synergies without validating feasibility, inflating valuations.
2. Ignoring Tech Debt: Legacy systems or outdated tech stacks increase integration costs, eroding deal value.
3. Underestimating Integration Costs: Cultural mismatches or complex IT integrations lead to unforeseen expenses.
4. Paying Peak-Cycle Multiples: High valuations in AI and SaaS, driven by market hype, risk overpayment if growth slows.
5. Misreading Customer Churn Risk: Inflated annual recurring revenue (ARR) projections often overlook retention challenges, leading to valuation errors.

• Due diligence pitfalls amplify these risks:

1. Inadequate IP Audits: Missing licensing issues or third-party dependencies can trigger legal liabilities.
2. Poor Quality of Earnings Review: Failing to adjust for non-recurring revenue distorts profitability.
3. Overlooking Off-Balance-Sheet Liabilities: Undisclosed litigation or regulatory fines create financial burdens.
4. Culture-Fit Mismatches: Poor alignment disrupts talent retention and integration.

Deal pricing traps include poorly structured earn-outs, unaccounted vendor dependencies, and hidden dilution risks from complex share structures, all contributing to overpayment risks.

3. Strategic Playbook to Mitigate Overpayment Risks

To navigate overpayment risks, IT leaders must adopt a disciplined approach across due diligence, financial controls, and governance:

• Robust Due Diligence

1. Tech Stack Audit: Evaluate the target’s infrastructure for tech debt, scalability, and cybersecurity vulnerabilities, ensuring compatibility with existing systems.
2. Customer Cohort Analysis: Validate ARR through retention rates and churn risk analysis to confirm revenue stability.
3. IP and Compliance Checks: Conduct thorough IP audits and ensure compliance with laws like the Digital India Act to avoid legal risks.
4. HR Integration Planning: Plan talent retention and cultural integration early to minimise disruption.

• Financial Guardrails

1. Independent Valuation Fairness Opinions: Engage SEBI-registered experts to provide objective valuation assessments, reducing overpayment risks.
2. Sensitivity Analysis: Model multiple scenarios (e.g., economic downturns, customer churn) to stress-test valuations.
3. Staggered Payments and Earn-Outs: Structure deals with performance-linked earn-outs and deferred payments to align price with outcomes, mitigating overpayment risks.

• Governance Safeguards

1. Audit Committee Oversight: Empower audit committees to scrutinise valuations and risks, ensuring independent review.
2. Legal Review of Reps and Warranties: Negotiate strong representations and warranties to cover financial, legal, and IP risks, with indemnification clauses for breaches.
3. Risk Allocation Clauses: Include material adverse change (MAC) provisions to protect against unforeseen liabilities.

Illustrative M&A Scenarios

• Successful Deal: Avoiding Overpayment Risks

A mid-cap IT firm targeting a $200 million AI startup conducted rigorous due diligence. Customer cohort analysis revealed high churn risk in the startup’s ARR, driven by short-term pilot contracts. Recognising overpayment risks, the firm negotiated a 20% lower price with a performance-based earn-out tied to retention. Post-deal, churn matched projections, and the earn-out adjusted the price, preserving shareholder value.

• Cautionary Tale: Valuation Errors in Action

A listed IT company acquired a GCC spinout for $1.2 billion, paying a 40% premium. Inadequate IP due diligence missed non-compliant software licenses, leading to $50 million in regulatory fines. Cultural mismatches further caused talent attrition, eroding shareholder value and highlighting the cost of overpayment risks.

Conclusion: Ensuring Sustainable IT M&A Success

India’s IT M&A market offers immense opportunities, but overpayment risks threaten deal success. By prioritising rigorous due diligence, clear valuation methods, and robust governance, leaders can mitigate valuation errors and align deal pricing with long-term value. SEBI’s guidelines reinforce the need for transparency and fairness, making disciplined M&A strategies essential for sustainable growth in India’s competitive IT sector.

About LawCrust

LawCrust Global Consulting Ltd. delivers cutting-edge Hybrid Consulting Solutions in Management, Finance, Technology, and Legal Consulting to ambitious businesses worldwide. Recognised for our cross-functional expertise and hybrid consulting approach, we empower startups, SMEs, and enterprises to scale efficiently, innovate boldly, and navigate complexity with confidence. Our services span key areas such as Investment Banking, Fundraising, Mergers & Acquisitions, Private Placement, and Debt Restructuring & Transformation, positioning us as a strategic partner for growth and resilience. With an integrated consulting model, fixed-cost engagements, and a virtual delivery framework, we make business transformation accessible, agile, and impactful.

For expert legal help, please contact us:

• Email: inquiry@lawcrustbusiness.com