The Challenge of Valuing Ecommerce Intangibles IBC Valuation of Ecommerce Intangibles

The primary challenge lies in the nature of intangible assets: they lack a physical form. For example, while a warehouse has a clear market value, a customer database’s worth depends on factors like data quality, customer lifetime value, and its potential for monetisation. This ambiguity poses a significant risk of undervaluation and can result in missed opportunities for creditors and investors during ecommerce insolvency.

Despite the fact that digital assets now comprise over 70% of enterprise value for tech firms (PwC), the IBBI (Valuation) Rules, 2017, don’t explicitly list intangible assets as a distinct class. This regulatory grey area often forces valuers to rely on subjective methods, leading to inconsistent outcomes.

Valuation IBC Valuation of Ecommerce Intangibles Methods for Digital Assets

Valuers must adapt existing methodologies to the unique characteristics of ecommerce intangibles. The most common approaches include:

• Income Approach: This method values an asset based on the future income it is expected to generate. It’s particularly useful for proprietary algorithms and customer databases that can be directly tied to revenue.
• Relief from Royalty Method: This technique estimates the value of an asset, such as a brand or trademark, by calculating the hypothetical cost a company would save by owning it instead of paying a licensing fee.
• Cost Approach: This assesses the cost required to recreate the asset, which is applicable to valuing tech platforms and backend systems.
• Market Approach: This method, though challenging due to the unique nature of most digital assets, benchmarks against similar transactions in the market to value assets like brand equity or domain names.

The Future of IBC and Intangible Assets

As India’s digital economy matures, the IBC valuation of ecommerce intangibles will become a central issue in insolvency proceedings. Regulatory reforms are expected to address the current gaps. The IBBI may add intangible asset classes to its guidelines. It could also encourage appointing specialised valuers with expertise in technology and intellectual property. Adopting international valuation standards from bodies like the IVSC would further standardise the process. This step ensures more transparent and fair outcomes.

A well-documented case study from 2023 demonstrates the impact of this shift: a mid-sized e-commerce firm’s customer database and proprietary software sold for ₹18 crore 50% more than its physical assets, highlighting the critical importance of a structured valuation process.

Strategic Recommendations

Business leaders and stakeholders should take a proactive approach to protect and maximise the value of their digital assets.

• Audit Intangibles: Regularly audit and formally document all intangible assets in your financial statements.
• Engage Experts: Do not wait for a crisis. Engage valuation professionals early on to accurately assess your digital assets.
• Advocate for Clarity: Participate in industry forums and advocate for regulatory reforms that will bring greater clarity to the IBC asset valuation framework for ecommerce insolvency.

Actionable Takeaways for Business Leaders

• Engage Licensed Professionals Early: Initiate valuation during the early stages of financial stress.
• Maintain Comprehensive Digital Asset Records: Track software, databases, and IP systematically.
• Understand Market Benchmarks: Use industry comparables to validate asset worth.
• Plan Strategic Recovery or Sale: Leverage valuations to inform restructuring, mergers, or acquisitions.

Adopting these practices ensures a more accurate and profitable recovery process under the IBC framework.

Conclusion: The Digital Gold Rush in Insolvency

The IBC valuation of ecommerce intangibles is no longer optional it’s essential. As intangible assets become the backbone of modern businesses, India’s insolvency regime must evolve to recognise and realise their true worth. Business leaders who understand this shift will be better positioned to navigate insolvency, drive strategic acquisitions, and protect stakeholder value.

About LawCrust

LawCrust Global Consulting Ltd. delivers cutting-edge Hybrid Consulting Solutions in Management, Finance, Technology, and Legal Consulting to ambitious businesses worldwide. Recognised for our cross-functional expertise and hybrid consulting approach, we empower startups, SMEs, and enterprises to scale efficiently, innovate boldly, and navigate complexity with confidence. Our services span key areas such as Investment Banking, Fundraising, Mergers & Acquisitions, Private Placement, and Debt Restructuring & Transformation, positioning us as a strategic partner for growth and resilience. With an integrated consulting model, fixed-cost engagements, and a virtual delivery framework, we make business transformation accessible, agile, and impactful.

For expert legal help, please contact us:

• Email: inquiry@lawcrustbusiness.com